Why Peoples First Insurance?

Peoples First Insurance is one of Florida’s oldest and most respected independent insurance, bonding and risk management providers. Our rich history started over 100 years ago in June 1912 when Black Insurance Agency was formed. Peoples First Insurance acquired the Agency and its staff in 2000, and merged core values of providing superior customer service and offering the most comprehensive range of insurance products sold under one roof.

These core values continue to live today with our staff of trained professionals that carry many of the highest designations within the insurance industry. Our plan is to continue to provide new and innovative ways of offering proactive insurance, bonding and risk management services to meet the unique needs of our clients and those in our community.

All your insurance needs in one place

Our team of insurance professionals is committed to helping families and businesses protect what’s most important to them. We have longstanding relationships with many of the top insurance companies in the country allowing us to find you the best coverage’s available at the most competitive prices.

Peoples First Insurance prides itself on being both a local provider for our individual clients and a national provider for our large businesses. We promise to provide you with the solutions and information you need to make and informed decision while offering helpful and personal service.

Your local provider for over 100 years

There is over 215 years of combined Insurance experience in our Panama City office and we are currently licensed in 7 states. Peoples First Insurance wrote over $16,500,000 in Property and Casualty premiums last year ranging from small commercial buildings to large Multi-Property Management companies. We are the top producing Insurance Agency in Bay and surrounding counties. Our message will not change and we continue to hold on to our roots planted almost 100 years ago.

Our mission is simple…

To be the number one insurance, bonding and risk management provider in our community by offering service, value and integrity that exceeds our client’s expectations.